2018 NCAA Seeding Questions

The NCAA has released its tournament brackets — it's a day we look forward to every year. But the next natural progression is to nitpick the seeds. That's fun too.

No doubt the seeding committee has a difficult task. So many factors are involved. And this year was as convoluted as ever with the overabundance of medical forfeits at conference tournaments. Overall, I thought they did a good job.

But, like every year, there seem to be inconsistencies. What matters? Wins? Losses? Recency? Conferences? Previous NCAA placement? 

There are decisions that left many scratching their heads heading into next week's NCAA tournament in Cleveland. I'll break them down here.

125: Lee at #3, Suriano at #4

These two seem inextricably linked. The long and short of it is this — Spencer Lee has two losses; Nick Suriano has none and he beat the guy (Ronnie Bresser) who beat Lee in a tournament they were both at.

On the other hand, Suriano wrestled one match at Big Tens, where Lee took third, losing to Nathan Tomasello. Lee also has a win over Tomasello, which is the best win among the two. 

Overall, it doesn't seem that egregious, but it certainly leaves one wondering how the committee settled on seeding Suriano below Lee.

Lee does have a win over the sixth-seed, Nick Piccininni, which no doubt helped his cause. And you have to harken back to think what could have happened had NATO wrestled Suriano when Rutgers dualed Ohio State.

141: Nick Lee at #8, Mikey Carr at #11

Nick Lee is a true freshman. Mikey Carr is a redshirt freshman. Both are having outstanding seasons, both have five losses, and both have one loss to a wrestler who isn't in the tournament. 

Lee lost to Kaden Gfeller (Oklahoma State). Carr lost to Max Murin (Iowa).

While Lee's other losses (Yianni Diakomihalis [3], Joey McKenna [4], Brock Zacherl [7]) are probably better than Carr's (McKenna [4], Jaydin Eierman [2], Mason Smith [10], and Tommy Thorn [unseeded]), the fact remains that Carr just beat (and outplaced) Lee at B1Gs. 

149: Justin Oliver at #6

OK, I get it: Justin Oliver was ranked fourth in the nation going into MACs. He had monster wins this year over Troy Heilmann (4), Ryan Deakin (7), Matt Kolodzik (11), and Colton McCrystal (13).

But the fact remains, Oliver lost to two unranked and unseeded wrestlers last week (one of whom had a 2-9 record) and needed an at-large berth to get in the tournament.

It's one thing to give a mulligan at the conference tournament and give a wild card; it's another thing altogether to have a disastrous conference tournament and maintain a top eight seed.

Another example that begs the question, "Do conferences even matter?"

157: Michael Kemerer at #6, Joey Lavallee at #2, Josh Shields at #4

The field at 157 didn't do the seeding committee any favors. Michael Kemerer, a returning All-American, and reigning NCAA champion Jason Nolf both entered Big Tens undefeated and leading contenders for the #1 and #2 seeds. Both nursing leg injuries, they defaulted to sixth.

Nolf wrestled (and won) two matches before defaulting to Alec Pantaleo in the semis. Kemerer won two matches before being pinned by Micah Jordan in semis.

The committee seeded Nolf (who technically has a loss on his record from when he defaulted to Rutgers' Van Brill) at #3. They put Kemerer, who has just the loss to Jordan, sixth.

Now, on one hand, everyone expressed their displeasure to all the medical forfeits at conferences (it's easy not to take a loss when you default). 

But if you compare the resumes of Kemerer, the sixth seed, and Joey Lavallee (2) and Joshua Shields (4), you're left scratching your head.

It's no secret Missouri wrestled a cupcake schedule. Sure, Lavallee has just one loss (so does Kemerer, by the way). But his best win is Archie Colgan, the #9.

Shields has two losses: one to Jordan, whom he also beat, and to Kemerer. 

So how in the Sam hell isn't Kemerer ahead of Shields (whom he beat head-to-head) and Shields ahead of Lavallee?

165: Walsh at #4

A returning All-American, Chad Walsh suffered his only loss on the year to Chance Marsteller, 8-4.

Walsh and Marsteller met for a second time in EWL finals, with Walsh winning 2-1.

Marsteller's only other loss was to the redshirting Bryce Steiert at the Scuffle. So it jumps off the page at you when you see Walsh as the four seed and Marsteller as the nine. They split, and outside of Walsh's win over Nick Wanzek (who is the 12 seed) their resumes are nearly identical.

But the scrutiny of Walsh's high seed doesn't end there.

How is he seeded ahead of Alex Marinelli (5), who has FOUR wins (Vincenzo Joseph [3], Richie Lewis [5], Logan Massa [7], and Chandler Rogers [8]) better than Walsh's best?!

You could say similar things for Lewis, whose wins are much better and whose losses are to just the top guys.

We heard the rhetoric that "losses don't matter; quality wins do." Walsh seeded ahead of Marinelli/Lewis/Massa/Evan Wick clearly contradicts that.

197: Moore at #1, Darmstadt at #2

Sure, 197 has been a mess all year. But riddle me this...

How does Kollin Moore, who has two losses (one of which was to a non-qualifier), get seeded ahead of Ben Darmstadt, who has a singular loss that he's since avenged twice?

"Quality wins," you say? Read the 165 write-up above.

#4 Travis Ford-Melton Commits To Purdue

113 lbs Semifinal - Travis Ford-Melton, IL vs Adam Busiello, NY

More big recruiting news today. Travis Ford-Melton released his college decision on social media, announcing he will be wrestling for the Purdue Boilermakers.

Decision Time For Cam Amine

152 lbs Round Of 128 - Cameron Amine, Michigan vs Braydon Huber, Idaho

Find a bucolic setting in Michigan and name it Amine Arbor.

Cohlton Schultz Wins Bronze, Andrew Berreyesa In World Finals

130kg, Final 3 of 3, Cohlton Schultz, NYAC vs Anthony Cassioppi, ISI

Team USA picked up two medals today in Greco-Roman at the Junior world championships. Cohlton Schultz won a bronze medal at 130kg and Andrew Berreyesa made the finals at 82kg.

Meet The Contenders: #1 Jakason Burks vs #2 Greg Diakomihalis

51 R16 - Greg Diakomihalis, FLWC vs Garett Lautzenheiser, Parkview

Jakason Burks has a big move arsenal and Greg Diakomihalis is nasty from an elbow tie. Burks is a walking warning sign when it comes to big throws while Greg D doesn’t always need to manufacture his own offense in order to score. 

FRL 317 - Penn State's Schedule, 125 and 133 Rankings Drop

FRL 317 discusses the Penn State wrestling schedule as well as the new NCAA rankings at 125 and 133 pounds.

Penn State Releases 2018-19 Schedule

174 lbs Round of 16 - Mark Hall, Penn State vs Hunter Bolen, Virginia Tech

The three-time defending national champion Penn State Nittany Lions have released their 2018-19 wrestling schedule.

Returning Division 1 All-Americans: 184lbs

184 lbs Semifinal - Taylor Venz, Nebraska vs Myles Martin, Ohio State

Now that preseason has officially started, pictures and videos are starting to filter in of teams practicing, all striving for the same goal: to win national championships and become All-Americans.

Ben Darmstadt Out, Ben Honis In For Cornell At 197

197 lbs Semifinal - Ben Darmstadt, Cornell vs Chris Weiler, Lehigh

Ben Darmstadt is likely to miss at least part of the the 2018-19 season due to injury. If possible (Ivy League has their own guidelines), Cornell may apply for a medical redshirt in the hopes of maintaining his final three years of eligibility.

#7 Theorius Robison Commits To Northern Colorado

132lbs Final: Carmen Ferrante, Bergen Catholic vs Theorius Robison, Pomona

Theorius Robison (Pomona, CO) has verbally committed to wrestle for the Northern Colorado Bears after high school.

Virginia Tech Recruiting Targets

Tony Robie is passing all the tests.

Join PRO Now to Get Unlimited Access to FloWrestling!

Join Now

Already a PRO Member? Log In