Questionable Call

2009 NCAA Coverage

Scott Trade Center  ⋅  St. Louis, MO, US  ⋅  Mar, 19 2009 - Mar 21 2009   |   Coverage created by Joe Williamson


   [ Add Photos ]   [ Add Videos ]


Get the Flash Player to see this player.
 URL: 

Enter Your Name

or Login Here
Please enter this code to post comment. Login to skip Captcha.
captcha img

#68
Kevin Menefee   August 21, 2009 at 9:04pm
Any good ref calls that fleeing. What happened before or after has no bearing on that call.
reply  
#67
I Want To See The Finals   June 9, 2009 at 5:05pm
Hey man, would you please upload the Lafayette vs. Pope finals, I want to show my dad my match.
reply  
#66
Just A Fan   March 23, 2009 at 11:43pm
Should have let them duke it out in OT. Okie kid iniated on line when was ref gona call them out? rediculous. Better luck next year kid.
reply  
#65
Iowa Fan..   March 22, 2009 at 12:28am
PISS POOR
reply  
#64
Me Again   March 21, 2009 at 3:08pm
Don Singles said:
From the 2009 NCAA Rule Book:
Rule 5.10.3: "Repeated movement away from the opponent without attempting a takedown is defined as fleeing the opponent and is stalling.

Rule 5.14 - Fleeing Wrestling Area
Fleeing or attempting to flee the wrestling area, or forcing, or attempting to force an opponent out of the wrestling area as a means of avoiding being scored upon, is a technical violation. Both wrestlers should make every effort to remain in bounds. Fleeing occurs any time a wrestler avoids wrestling by intentionally going or trying to go out of bounds, by pulling or attempting to pull the opponent out of bounds or by pushing or attempting to push the opponent out of bounds. Fleeing the wrestling area shall not follow the disqualification sequence. The penalty shall be one point for each infraction.
Whether this is called 4%, 44% or 94% of the time is irrelevent. The rule says what it says and the ref made the call based on the rule and it was the right call.
Thank you for that rule. THIS SOLVES IT.... Dennis was pushing Notte out of bounds the entire match. Therefore be consistant and award Notte his penalty points too. Having said that Notte won the match. Watch the whole thing. In fact, go back and watch the same two at OSU in Jan. Notte won that match too. According to the rule you just posted.
reply  
#63
Just Me   March 21, 2009 at 3:02pm
That's only a clip of the match... Chris wrestled agressively the entire match. If your going to through penalty points out there Dennis should have been hit for stalling. They both got a TD and an Escape. With 30 seconds left let them duke it out in OT. Besides Notte initiated the move and had Dennis' arm. Bad call...
reply  
#62
Matref0   March 21, 2009 at 10:42am
Here is one from the medal round 2 yrs ago. Much more questionable than the Iowa/Ok St one:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBkjd6iwpY4
reply  
#61
Tom Hunter   March 21, 2009 at 10:15am
sorry about the spelling of "NOT"!
reply  
#60
Tom Hunter   March 21, 2009 at 10:14am
the real problem was the ref didn't call Dennis for stalling throughout the period and this attempt by OkSt. The "fleeing the mat" call was questionable; I've seen many exact replicas NOT called, and a lesser percentage called. I'm retired, but used to Ref High School matches and tournaments.
I would NOPT have made the call. th
reply  
#59
Anonymous Coward   March 21, 2009 at 9:59am
He fleed the mat. It's a rule, and refs should enforce the rules no matter what tournament it's at.
reply  
#58
Ref   March 21, 2009 at 8:32am
I ref and this fits the definition of fleeing the mat, however I would never make this call to decide a match in the NCAA's because the wrestler from okst initiated the action!! Im sure others see it differently but its bull when ref's decide matches rather than the wrestlers ...
reply  
#57
Anonymous Coward   March 21, 2009 at 12:00am
who won?
reply  
#56
Sierra149lbs   March 20, 2009 at 5:57pm
That call was a terrible call for sure but thats the NCAA'S nothing is ever perfect!!!
reply  
#55
Hawkeyes Are Tools   March 20, 2009 at 5:30pm
that call was terrible.... dennis was fleeing for sure
reply  
#54
Mark Niemann   March 20, 2009 at 2:30pm
I made sure not to read any of the comments before viewing or posting...

I think it was fleeing as I understand the rule.
Now that I have read the comments, Sam is right on. Call the correct way, all the time and there is no contrversy.
reply  
#53
Sam   March 20, 2009 at 2:27pm
If that call was made regularly in that situation, then it may have been a decent call. But fleeing is rarely if ever called and in that situation, after having initiated the action, it was a poor one.
reply  
#52
Kaiser Kaiser   March 20, 2009 at 2:25pm
no..
reply  
#51
Q   March 20, 2009 at 1:13pm
Good call. Coaches at all levels would tell you to circle and not be so blatant about going out of bounds.
reply  
#50
Joe O'Gorman   March 20, 2009 at 12:47pm
Chris Notte may have won this match and did not because he did not wrestle aggressively enough and did not do well on the edge of the mat. Whether or not it should have been called a "fleeing the mat", and in my opinion it was a reasonable call, I think Notte should have countered the move more aggressively and tried for a stalemate or a good scramble. If one thinks it was a questionable call, one should admit that Chris should have wrestled more aggressively to win and if he had wrestled more aggressively the call would not have been made as it was made. Notte has an excellent future as a Division I wrestler and this moment will stay with him, fuel him to excel, and school him on better tactics. Chris had an excellent first season in DI and lost to an outstanding wrestler. Chris will perform even better in his next season.
reply  
#49
Gaskill   March 20, 2009 at 11:53am
Chris was def. fleeing the mat this is college wrestling he's gotta be working for more..he knows where the out of bounds is he needs to move in. Was not a questionable call.
reply  
#48
Wrestler4life   March 20, 2009 at 10:02am
Have to agree with Brian, its the big show and you know whats on the line here. He was fleeing, where the hell else was he going, to grab a drink?
reply  
#47
Matref0   March 20, 2009 at 9:42am
I can live with this call. OK St was dragging IA out of bounds. Text book flee IMO. The problem is it is not called much during the regular season and it should be.

If you think I'm full of crap, if this was a bad call, John Smith would have went nuts and they would have been at the table arguing it. He told his wrestler to stay on the mat.
Of course the Iowa fans applaud this call.
reply  
#46
Anonymous Coward   March 20, 2009 at 9:42am
bad call
reply  
#45
Mikeb   March 20, 2009 at 9:41am
bad call
reply  
#44
Brian Brubaker   March 20, 2009 at 9:10am
With that being said....It IS THE NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP and you should not even make the ref THINK your fleeing!
reply  
#43
Open Up   March 20, 2009 at 8:03am
Yeah, I can see how the ref could see that as fleeing.
BUT, this is the national championships and you should let them wrestle for it.
reply  
#42
Anonymous Coward   March 20, 2009 at 7:44am
absolutely terrible call
reply  
#41
Wrestler1   March 20, 2009 at 3:44am
Probaby a good call. Gotta do a better job of selling when you are fleeing on the edge.
reply  
#40
Just Terrible   March 20, 2009 at 1:39am
Year round preparation to have the match decided by a highly subjective, extremely inconsistent, questionable and just plain ridiculous call.
reply  
#39
IL Wrestling   March 20, 2009 at 1:07am
that was a good call...nothing wrong
reply  
#38
Anonymous Coward   March 20, 2009 at 12:45am
John Smith sure didn't seem like he was suprised that it was called.
reply  
#37
Barcarn22   March 20, 2009 at 12:40am
what year is notte? (reppin nj wrestling...holy spirt)
reply  
#36
Don Singles   March 19, 2009 at 11:55pm
From the 2009 NCAA Rule Book:
Rule 5.10.3: "Repeated movement away from the opponent without attempting a takedown is defined as fleeing the opponent and is stalling.

Rule 5.14 - Fleeing Wrestling Area
Fleeing or attempting to flee the wrestling area, or forcing, or attempting to force an opponent out of the wrestling area as a means of avoiding being scored upon, is a technical violation. Both wrestlers should make every effort to remain in bounds. Fleeing occurs any time a wrestler avoids wrestling by intentionally going or trying to go out of bounds, by pulling or attempting to pull the opponent out of bounds or by pushing or attempting to push the opponent out of bounds. Fleeing the wrestling area shall not follow the disqualification sequence. The penalty shall be one point for each infraction.
Whether this is called 4%, 44% or 94% of the time is irrelevent. The rule says what it says and the ref made the call based on the rule and it was the right call.
reply  
#35
Johann Gerlach   March 19, 2009 at 11:46pm
Very tough call but I can see some mat fleeing. OSU's got a russian 2 on 1 and he's pulling him off. Shouldn't be the call that decides a match at Nationals though. That's a first tournament of the yr call. Ref made a boo boo. You're there to let these kids decide what's up, not be the cool-guy ref.
reply  
#34
Codyingle   March 19, 2009 at 11:41pm
def the right call he was walking of the mat and not trying to defend the low ankle of dennis
reply  
#33
James   March 19, 2009 at 11:26pm
without a doubt the right call
reply  
#32
TJ X   March 19, 2009 at 10:47pm
100% correct call and the TJ X man will explain and let this be a lesson to all young wrestlers coming up, no matter what level you are: When you are on the edge, you ALWAYS fight into the man, NEVER EVER EVER pull your man off or appear to flee the mat. I don't care if rabbit kicking is a bona fide defense, doesn't matter at all. Edge wrestling is a game of PERCEPTION and when a referee sees one man in on an opponent's legs and the other man appears to be running away, it looks like fleeing PERIOD and you are going to get whacked, AND HE DID. Always thrust your hips inward, get on those hands, kill the opponent's head, shoelaces to the mat, and KEEP WRESTLING!!! This was fleeing and not only would I have called this guy but I would have disqualified him and kicked his family out of the stadium because I hate Okie State anyways.
reply  
#31
Lammergeier   March 19, 2009 at 10:45pm
Give me an F'ing break on OSU not being well conditioned. Hendricks is the greatest conditioned athlete of all time. Ask people if Pendleton had no gas? How about Rosholt? Get out.
reply  
#30
LOCK UP AND TOSS   March 19, 2009 at 10:38pm
GREAT CALL REF!!
reply  
#29
Cornell Fan   March 19, 2009 at 10:35pm
FLEEING FOR SURE
reply  
#28
Brian Brubaker   March 19, 2009 at 10:31pm
Regardless of whether or not he was just trying to score....he DID flee he pulled Dennis out of bounds!
reply  
#27
I Hate State   March 19, 2009 at 10:12pm
anonymous coward likes to suck wrestlers choads!
reply  
#26
Come On Ref   March 19, 2009 at 9:57pm
Chris tries to score,and the ref should have given them a fresh start, out of bounds. No flee no stall, let the guys wrestle.Then notte goes to wrestlebacks and hits the 3rd seed that was upset to go to wrestlebacks first match. Ncaa's is over for notte, that sucks. Keep your head up kid, and good luck next year.
reply  
#25
Anonymous Coward   March 19, 2009 at 9:56pm
not called enough...you cant pull someone out...and i am much more of an OSU fan than an Iowa
reply  
#24
Julio   March 19, 2009 at 9:41pm
WOW! terrrrible call. dennis is a chronic stall artist who never gets called! notte initiated the takedown and took two steps back to balance himself. straight screw job.
reply  
#23
Notsure   March 19, 2009 at 9:34pm
i dont understand this call...think about it people.. if this happens in the center of the mat...the guy is probably going to do the same thing when it comes to a low single at least..if u cant sprawl your only options is to try and kick out
reply  
#22
Tough Call   March 19, 2009 at 9:33pm
It did not look as if notte was making an attempt to stay on the mat. He peeled the hand off his leg and slowly eased himself off the mat.
reply  
#21
Bad Call IMHO   March 19, 2009 at 9:27pm
First of all, the kid from OSU wasn't stalling, he took the first shot. More importantly, how else do you propose he defended the leg in a manner more efficent. He did what almost any wrestler in that situation would have done, thus, I disagree with the ref's call. If referees in general made fleeing the mat calls more often this wouldn't even be an issue.
reply  
#20
Ed The Doober   March 19, 2009 at 9:04pm
GREAT CALL!!! I hate stallers and jagoffs who don't want to wrestle and I want to see Dennis go all the way.
reply  
#19
Anonymous Coward   March 19, 2009 at 8:50pm
Was this overtime?
reply  
#18
Anonymous Coward   March 19, 2009 at 8:48pm
i think that dennis should get a new pair of shoes noting have some JV shoes bro come on ur in college
reply  
#17
Craig Davis   March 19, 2009 at 8:47pm
That was as good call if he wasnt fleeing he made it look that way
reply  
#16
Mike Glaberman   March 19, 2009 at 8:27pm
tough tough call
reply  
#15
Brandon Hancock   March 19, 2009 at 8:18pm
right call, he was just scooting out of bounds like a lil .
reply  
#14
Kniggit   March 19, 2009 at 8:18pm
That call might be made 4% of the time during the season
reply  
#13
Vance   March 19, 2009 at 8:16pm
i dont agree with the call, whistle them out of bounds and let the wrestlers decide the outcome!
reply  
#12
Dckundr   March 19, 2009 at 8:07pm
right call
reply  
#11
Unbiased   March 19, 2009 at 7:49pm
In my opinion he was fleeing the mat. He dragged Dennis 3 or 4 steps, and didnt appear to be trying any other counter.
reply  
#10
MonsterStatus   March 19, 2009 at 7:24pm
I don't believe he was intentionally fleeing, however, the way the rule is interpreted he could have still defended the shot on the mat and tried to keep it on the mat (although he probably would have been taken down at the edge if he did so). Can't say I like it, but I think it was the correct call to make.
reply  
#9
Rob Spallone   March 19, 2009 at 7:08pm
no way! def. not fleeing that was a total BS call
reply  
#8
Cowboys   March 19, 2009 at 7:06pm
Horrible call! You have to run flagrantly out of bounds to be called for fleeing. To Coach McStupid. OSU has stalled their way to 34 national titles.
reply  
#7
Don Singles   March 19, 2009 at 7:04pm
The rule states that you can not leave the mat to avoid a take down. While defending a take down in that manner is perfectly normal, doing so at the edge of the mat is a penalty. The only bad call here would be a no call.
reply  
#6
Anonymous Coward   March 19, 2009 at 7:04pm
he didnt defend into him....but probably should not be called.
reply  
#5
Bob VanWinkle   March 19, 2009 at 6:58pm
watched it several times, looks like a very questionable call..
One of the first things my coach always said...never let a ref decide a match!!!
reply  
#4
Kehs   March 19, 2009 at 6:57pm
Good call. Too bad OSU.
reply  
#3
Anonymous Coward   March 19, 2009 at 6:34pm
he's obviously pulling him out of bounds and pulling his leg out, where is the "questionableness" here
reply  
#2
Gary DeRaad   March 19, 2009 at 6:30pm
OSU has been fleeing the mat forever, they are, and have always been a skilled but poorly conditioned and not very aggressive team. They always run rather than turn and fight a takedown.
reply  
#1
MAJOR OSU FAN   March 19, 2009 at 6:29pm
BULL$^&*!!!!!!!
reply  

Questionable Call

NCAAs are full of tight calls here is one that decided the match. Is it the right call?
March 19, 2009
Tags:
No Tags Yet.

Rate this Video
4.6/5 (9 votes cast)
Fall Report
Final Agate
Final Brackets
Final Summary
Final Team Results
Final Team Standings

2007 NCAA Championships
2008 NCAA Championships
2009 NCAA Preview Page
Stachies at Nashies And More
Regular Season Coverage of Weight Classes
125 lbs
133 lbs
141 lbs
149 lbs
157 lbs
165 lbs
174 lbs
184 lbs
197 lbs
285 lbs
2009 NCAA Brackets

Videos

Coach Tom Brands (Iowa) press conference after Iowa won the 2009 NCAA team titleCoach Tom Brands (Iowa) press conference after Iowa won the 2009 NCAA team title
Martin Gets Taken Down By Bishop For A HeadbandMartin Gets Taken Down By Bishop For A Headband
Caldwell Warm UpCaldwell Warm Up
Pre Metcalf Caldwell matchPre Metcalf Caldwell match
Ohio State on the stageOhio State on the stage
Metcalf prematchMetcalf prematch
Mark Ellis walking to media roomMark Ellis walking to media room
Jarrod King hanging outJarrod King hanging out
Jake Varner prepping for FinalsJake Varner prepping for Finals
Iowa and Ohio St backstageIowa and Ohio St backstage
Ellis CelebrationEllis Celebration
Darrion Caldwell OWDarrion Caldwell OW
Herbert and Pucillo talking prematchHerbert and Pucillo talking prematch
Gomez right before he wrestlesGomez right before he wrestles
Casey Cunningham give words of prep to Old teammateCasey Cunningham give words of prep to Old teammate
Gomez after victoryGomez after victory
Caldwell with his trophyCaldwell with his trophy
Burroughs after NCAA championshipBurroughs after NCAA championship
Buroughs celebrationBuroughs celebration
9 champs on the stage9 champs on the stage
Varner SignitureVarner Signiture
Tom Ryan Wathing HumphreyTom Ryan Wathing Humphrey
Pucillo And Tom Ryan After FinalsPucillo And Tom Ryan After Finals
Nickerson And HahnNickerson And Hahn
Miller PrematchMiller Prematch
Jaggers WarmupJaggers Warmup
Ellis CelebrationEllis Celebration
Burroughs Before FinalBurroughs Before Final

Others

At the MatGuard RVAt the MatGuard RV
Iowa on the stageIowa on the stage
Miller prepping for finalsMiller prepping for finals
Mike Miller before the finalsMike Miller before the finals
Jarrod King and Coaches After FinalsJarrod King and Coaches After Finals
Mark Ellis after semisMark Ellis after semis
Caldwell warming upCaldwell warming up
Umbeuhauer crying after thrilling victory over Keddy in QuartersUmbeuhauer crying after thrilling victory over Keddy in Quarters
Top of RVTop of RV

Highlights

Thats BrandstasticThats Brandstastic

Interviews

Not much strategy in wrestling HumphreyNot much strategy in wrestling Humphrey
Iowa Coach Tom Brands interview after Iowa takes team lead at 2009 NCAA ChampionshipsIowa Coach Tom Brands interview after Iowa takes team lead at 2009 NCAA Championships
Jake Herbert Is Newly SingleJake Herbert Is Newly Single
Steve Luke National ChampionSteve Luke National Champion
Pucillo a new strategy for next yearPucillo a new strategy for next year
Max Askren fifth place finishMax Askren fifth place finish
Mark Manning on the mental strength of BuroughsMark Manning on the mental strength of Buroughs
Mark Cody bringing success to AmericanMark Cody bringing success to American
Manning congratulates PoetaManning congratulates Poeta
Konrad as close as they comeKonrad as close as they come
Kerry McCoy post top ten performance for MarylandKerry McCoy post top ten performance for Maryland
Jared Frayer pre Brent Metcalf BoutJared Frayer pre Brent Metcalf Bout
Ellis remembersEllis remembers
Cody Sandersonon Varner coming throughCody Sandersonon Varner coming through
Carter Jordan on DCs great matchCarter Jordan on DCs great match
Goldman gives breakdown of IndianaGoldman gives breakdown of Indiana
All Things are possible through God, Franklin GomezAll Things are possible through God, Franklin Gomez
Troy Sutherland On 2009 NCAAsTroy Sutherland On 2009 NCAAs
Tom Ryan Buckeyes Finish SecondTom Ryan Buckeyes Finish Second
McFarland After Luke FinalMcFarland After Luke Final
Jake Herbert After Finals VictoryJake Herbert After Finals Victory
Jaggers Celebration and InterviewJaggers Celebration and Interview
Borelli After Miller LossBorelli After Miller Loss
Bold Suit Bold PerformanceBold Suit Bold Performance
Metcalf After Loss In The FinalsMetcalf After Loss In The Finals
Caldwell Defeats MetcalfCaldwell Defeats Metcalf
Umbehauer FInishes 3rdUmbehauer FInishes 3rd
Scott Sentes Gets 7thScott Sentes Gets 7th
Ryan Mornigstar Clutch WinsRyan Mornigstar Clutch Wins
Popolizio and Papadatos On PattersonPopolizio and Papadatos On Patterson
Maryland With Three AAsMaryland With Three AAs
Kent State With 2 AAsKent State With 2 AAs
Kennedy wrestles 9 matches and gets 5thKennedy wrestles 9 matches and gets 5th
Josh Patterson Binghamtons First AAJosh Patterson Binghamtons First AA
Jayson Ness third PlaceJayson Ness third Place
Hudson Taylor 3rd Place And Some New MagicHudson Taylor 3rd Place And Some New Magic
Gary Taylor On DougGary Taylor On Doug
Chandler FInally Gets His AA StatusChandler FInally Gets His AA Status
Bedelyon All American Kent StateBedelyon All American Kent State
Anthony Robles After NCAAsAnthony Robles After NCAAs
Alex Krom They Messed Up My SeedAlex Krom They Messed Up My Seed
Nickerson at Press ConferenceNickerson at Press Conference
Paul Donahoe in press conferencePaul Donahoe in press conference
Mike Poeta returns to finalsMike Poeta returns to finals
Konrad Dudziak all smilesKonrad Dudziak all smiles
Jaggers makes finalsJaggers makes finals
Caldwell prepping for the finalsCaldwell prepping for the finals
Sanders is an All American.Sanders is an All American.
Another Minnesota Silver Lining, Tyler SafratowichAnother Minnesota Silver Lining, Tyler Safratowich
Stevie Martin got one in the finalsStevie Martin got one in the finals
Ryan Williams Press ConferenceRyan Williams Press Conference
NCAA Finalist only took 7th at statesNCAA Finalist only took 7th at states
Nicholas Bedelyon Kent All AmericanNicholas Bedelyon Kent All American
A Wild Card Qualifier to All AmericanA Wild Card Qualifier to All American
Pucillo in the finalsPucillo in the finals
Joe LeBlanc All AmericanJoe LeBlanc All American
LeBlanc CelebrationLeBlanc Celebration
Jake Herbert going for 2Jake Herbert going for 2
One hell of a matchOne hell of a match
ODU Williams gets to SemisODU Williams gets to Semis
Robles gets into SemisRobles gets into Semis
Golden Flashes punch one throughGolden Flashes punch one through
Max Askren over the hump into SemisMax Askren over the hump into Semis
Brandon Browne into Semis for NebraskaBrandon Browne into Semis for Nebraska
Boise State pulls out victory in QuartersBoise State pulls out victory in Quarters
Rider Pulls out big victory with Jersey FreshRider Pulls out big victory with Jersey Fresh
Leens Pep TalkLeens Pep Talk
Tom Ryan in the middle of a big QF RoundTom Ryan in the middle of a big QF Round
Lance Palmer has been visualizing this matchLance Palmer has been visualizing this match
Dukes first AADukes first AA
Highest seed wrestler in itHighest seed wrestler in it
Darrion Caldwell on semis and metcalfDarrion Caldwell on semis and metcalf
Metcalf strategy vs Lance PalmerMetcalf strategy vs Lance Palmer
You need to Believe vs HerbertYou need to Believe vs Herbert
Tough Day for Cornell Day1Tough Day for Cornell Day1
Tom Brands gets six into quartersTom Brands gets six into quarters
Pritzlaff after a couple of upsetsPritzlaff after a couple of upsets
Jenson gives us the scoopJenson gives us the scoop
Krom makes into Quarters for MarylandKrom makes into Quarters for Maryland
Charles believes in EllisCharles believes in Ellis
Boise State punches 4 to QuartersBoise State punches 4 to Quarters
3 into Quarters for Golden Flashes3 into Quarters for Golden Flashes
Mike Poeta After Round 2Mike Poeta After Round 2
Darrion CaldwellDarrion Caldwell
Ryan PraterRyan Prater
Nick NelsonNick Nelson
Nick Nelson and his stacheNick Nelson and his stache
Drew LashawayDrew Lashaway
Trenton WashingtonTrenton Washington
Ryan PatrovichRyan Patrovich
Marcus HoehnMarcus Hoehn
David MarbleDavid Marble
Andrew RendosAndrew Rendos
Ready For NationalsReady For Nationals
Jordan BurroughsJordan Burroughs
Craig Brester Bridging The GapCraig Brester Bridging The Gap
Brandon BrownBrandon Brown