Every Returning NCAA Wrestling All-American This Season (2023-2024)

Every Returning NCAA Wrestling All-American This Season (2023-2024)

A list of every past NCAA wrestling All-American that will be competing this season.

Oct 14, 2023 by JD Rader
Every Returning NCAA Wrestling All-American This Season (2023-2024)

Wrestling season is here. While new names will surely arise and establish themselves, here are the men who have already proven themselves to be the best wrestlers in the country.

125

Returning 2023 All-Americans

Matt Ramos - 2nd

Anthony Noto -  4th

Eddie Ventresca - 7th


Other All-Americans In The Field

Patrick McKee - 3rd in 2021, 5th in 2022

Michael DeAugustino - 4th in 2022

Eric Barnett - 8th in 2021, 7th in 2022

Brandon Kaylor - 8th in 2022


133

Returning 2023 All-Americans

Vito Arujau - Champ

Daton Fix - 4th

Aaron Nagao - 5th

Sam Latona - 7th

Kai Orine - 8th


Other All-Americans In The Field

Lucas Byrd - 5th in 2021 and 2022

Chris Cannon - 7th in 2021 and 2022


141

Returning 2023 All-Americans

Real Woods - 2nd

Beau Bartlett - 3rd

Lachlan McNeil - 4th

Clay Carlson - 5th

Brock Hardy - 6th


Other All-Americans In The Field

Jesse Mendez - 6th at 133 in 2023

Cole Matthews - 5th in 2022

CJ Composto - 8th in 2022


149

Returning 2023 All-Americans

Shayne Van Ness - 3rd

Kyle Parco - 4th

Caleb Henson - 5th

Brock Mauller - 7th


Other All-Americans In The Field

Ridge Lovett - 2nd in 2022

Jaden Abas - 7th in 2021

Dylan D'Emilio - 8th at 141


157

Returning 2023 All-Americans

Levi Haines - 2nd 

Jared Franek - 4th 

Ed Scott - 5th 

Peyton Robb - 6th 

Bryce Andonian - 7th 

Will Lewan - 8th 


Other All-Americans In The Field

Jacori Teemer - 4th in 2021 and 6th in 2022 at 157 lbs

Michael Blockhus - 8th at 149  in 2023

Brayton Lee - 6th at 157 in 2021


165 lbs

Returning 2023 All-Americans

Keegan O’Toole - Champ

David Carr - 2nd 

Cam Amine - 4th

DJ Hamiti - 6th

Michael Caliendo - 7th

Izzak Olejnik - 8th


Other All-Americans In The Field

Peyton Hall - 8th in 2022


174

Returning 2023 All-Americans

Carter Starocci - Champ

Chris Foca - 3rd 

Mekhi Lewis - 4th 

Nelson Brands - 5th 

Peyton Mocco - 8th 


Other All-Americans In The Field

Shane Griffith - 1st in 2021, 2nd in 2022, and 5th in 2023 at 165

Carson Kharchla - 7th at 165 in 2022

Travis Wittlake - 4th at 165 in 2021

Jackson Turley- 8th in 2021


184

Returning 2023 All-Americans

Parker Keckeisen - 2nd

Trey Munoz - 6th

Will Feldkamp - 7th

Gavin Kane - 8th


Other All-Americans In The Field

Bernie Truax - 4th at 174 in 2021, 4th at 184 in 2022, 4th at 197 in 2023

Dustin Plott - 6th at 174 in 2022 and 2023

Jonathan Loew - 8th in 2022


197

Returning 2023 All-Americans

Tanner Sloan - 2nd

Rocky Elam - 3rd

Jacob Cardenas - 8th


Other All-Americans In The Field

Aaron Brooks - 1st at 184 in 2021, 2022, and 2023

Stephen Buchanan - 8th in 2021 and 3rd in 2022

Trent Hidlay - 2nd in 2021, 5th in 2022, and 4th in 2023 at 184

Michael Beard - 7th in 2021

Gavin Hoffman - 6th in 2022

John Poznanski - 4th at 184 in 2021


285

Returning 2023 All-Americans

Greg Kerkvliet - 2nd

Wyatt Hendrickson - 3rd

Tony Cassioppi - 4th

Lucas Davison - 5th

Zach Elam - 6th

Cohlton Schultz - 7th


Other All-Americans In The Field

Yonger Bastida - 5th at 197 in 2022